Home / Projects / Chiesina delle Carceri← All projects
Conservative restoration · Seismic improvement · 2016–2017

Oratory of San Carlo,
the “Chiesina delle Carceri”

Fivizzano · Baroque architecture by Giovan Battista Foggini, 1706
Design and site supervision · Arch. Stefano Santini

Oratory of San Carlo before restoration, historic photograph
BEFORE — historic photograph of the façade
Oratory of San Carlo after restoration
AFTER — the oratory once restoration was complete, 2017
01 — History
CONSTRUCTION
1706, commissioned by Carlo Vieri, governor of Lunigiana
ARCHITECT
Giovan Battista Foggini
LOCATION
Via Umberto I, historic centre of Fivizzano
RESTORATION
2016–2017 · inaugurated on 2 June 2017
ROLE
Designer and site supervisor
CLIENT
Municipality of Fivizzano

A small Baroque church on the main street of Fivizzano’s historic centre, between Porta Sarzanese – the “Lower Gate” – and Piazza Medicea. Its entrance opens onto the small square in front of the town hall, which originally housed the Court and the Prisons (carceri).

The oratory was built in 1706 by Carlo Vieri, governor of Lunigiana, “opposite the prisons”, so that the inmates could attend Mass at least on holy days, as recorded in parish file no. 47 kept in the Diocesan Historical Archive of Sarzana. The building already appears in the Fivizzano land registers of 1702.

Until the 1920 earthquake it had a bell tower, visible in 17th- and 18th-century views of Fivizzano, which rose above the sacristy behind the altar: two barrel-vaulted storeys in edge-laid stone survive, like the vault of the church. The plan and volume are regular and symmetrical; the gabled roof protects a shallow stone dome decorated with stuccoes and tempera.

02 — The restoration

Guiding principle: reversibility of the structural works and compatibility of the materials with the existing fabric.

The conservative restoration was developed on two parallel levels.

LEVEL 1 · STRUCTURE

Seismic improvement

The most important level: improving the building’s response to earthquakes and reducing their effects, with reversible metal tie rods and ring beams.

LEVEL 2 · MATERIAL

Treating decay

Countering decay caused by weathering and damp, with traditional techniques and breathable natural-lime mortars, to preserve the oratory and the works it houses.

Anchor plate of a metal tie rod on the stone corner
Anchor plate of the new tie rods, specially designed to recall the shape of a pen nib, in homage to the remains of Giovanni Fantoni (Labindo) kept in the oratory with his memorial stone. It also has a structural function: it spreads the loads over a larger area of the masonry wall and improves the connection with the horizontal structure.
Historic drawing of the oratory altar
Historic drawing of the altar and apse of the oratory.
Inauguration of the restoration of the Oratory of San Carlo, 2 June 2017
Inauguration of the restoration, 2 June 2017, in the presence of Eugenio Giani, then President of the Regional Council of Tuscany, the Mayor of Fivizzano Cav. Paolo Grassi and the President of the Order of Architects of Florence Arch. Roberto Masini.
Arch. Stefano Santini · Order of Architects, Planners, Landscape Architects and Conservators of Massa-Carrara (Italy) · VAT 01227150453 Privacy · Cookies